Loading...
City Council Meeting Agenda Packet 8-2-20221 CITY OF HUNTSVILLE, TEXAS Andy Brauninger, Mayor Bert Lyle, Position 1 At-Large Dee Howard Mullins, Position 2 At-Large Vicki McKenzie, Position 3 At-Large Pat Graham, Position 4 At-Large Daiquiri Beebe, Ward 1 Russell Humphrey, Mayor Pro Tem, Ward 2 Deloris Massey, Ward 3 Jon Strong, Ward 4 HUNTSVILLE CITY COUNCIL AGENDA TUESDAY, AUGUST 2, 2022 JOINT WORKSHOP WITH PLANNING COMMISSION 5:00 P.M. – Huntsville Public Library Staggs Community Room, 1219 13th Street, Huntsville, Texas REGULAR SESSION 6:00 P.M. - City Council Chambers WORKSHOP Immediately following Regular Session – Large Conference Room Huntsville City Hall, 1212 Avenue M, Huntsville, Texas, 77340 Persons with disabilities who plan to attend this meeting and may need auxiliary aids or services are requested to contact the City Secretary’s office (936.291.5413) two working days prior to the meeting for appropriate arrangements. JOINT WORKSHOP WITH PLANNING COMMISSION (5:00 p.m.) Huntsville Public Library DISCUSSION a. Receive Consultant's Recommendations on Development Districts Armon Irones, City Planner MAIN SESSION (6:00 p.m.) CALL TO ORDER INVOCATION AND PLEDGES - U.S. Flag and Texas Flag: Honor the Texas Flag. I pledge allegiance to thee, Texas, one state, under God, one, and indivisible. PUBLIC HEARING a. Public Hearing to hear testimony concerning the consideration of a Conditional Use Permit Application for the creation of a Vehicle Maintenance Shop to be developed on property located at I-45 North Feeder Road on Walker County Property ID #34333. Armon Irones, City Planner 1. CONSENT AGENDA The presiding officer will call for public comments before action is taken on these items. (Approval of Consent Agenda authorizes the City Manager to implement each item in accordance with staff recommendations. An item may be removed from the Consent Agenda and added to the Statutory Agenda for full discussion by request of a member of Council.) a. Consider approving the Minutes from the July 19, 2022, Regular City Council Meeting Kristy Doll, City Secretary b. Consider adoption of Ordinance 2022-22 to amend the budget for FY 21-22 and/or CIP Project budgets Page 1 of 41 2 c. Consider authorizing the City Manager to enter into an agreement with LJA Engineering for professional engineering services for the CIP FY 21-22 Storm Sewer Replacement Projects. Kathlie Jeng-Bulloch, City Engineer 2. STATUTORY AGENDA a. Consider approving a Conditional Use Permit Application for the creation of a Vehicle Maintenance Shop to be developed on property located at I-45 North Feeder Road on Walker County Property ID #34333. Armon Irones, City Planner b. FIRST READING: Consider authorizing the City Manager to award and enter into a contract with Frost Construction for Construction Services on the redesigned Martin Luther King Jr. Community Center Renovation Project. Rick Rudometkin, Deputy City Manager Penny Joiner, Director of Parks and Leisure c. Consider approval of announcing the City Council’s intention to adopt a tax rate in compliance with the Texas State’s Truth in Taxation laws; a rate not to exceed $0.3075 per $100 valuation for the City’s 2022 – 2023 Fiscal Year (Tax Year 2022). Roll call vote Steve Ritter, Finance Director 3. CITY COUNCIL/MAYOR/CITY MANAGER 4. REQUESTS FOR CITIZEN PARTICIPATION (An opportunity for citizens to be heard on any topic and for the City Council to participate in the discussion. No action will be taken.) a. Airianna Mckibbins - Reliable public transportation Airianna Mckibbins 5. MEDIA INQUIRIES RELATED TO MATTERS ON THE AGENDA 6. ITEMS OF COMMUNITY INTEREST ADJOURNMENT *If during the course of the meeting and discussion of any items covered by this notice, City Council determines that a Closed or Executive session of the Council is required, then such closed meeting will be held as authorized by Texas Government Code, Chapter 551, Section 551.071 – consultation with counsel on legal matters; 551.072 – deliberation regarding purchase, exchange, lease or value of real property; 551.073 – deliberation regarding a prospective gift; 551.074 – personnel matters regarding the appointment, employment, evaluation, reassignment, duties, discipline, or dismissal of a public officer or employee; 551.076 – implementation of security personnel or devices; 551.087 – deliberation regarding economic development negotiation; Sec. 551.089 - deliberation regarding security devices or security audits; and/or other matters as authorized under the Texas Government Code. If a Closed or Executive session is held in accordance with the Texas Government Code as set out above, the City Council will reconvene in Open Session to take action, if necessary, on the items addressed during Executive Session. WORKSHOP (Immediately following Regular Session) Discussion a. Receive a presentation on the FY 22-23 Capital Improvement Program Kathlie Jeng-Bulloch, City Engineer Page 2 of 41 3 CERTIFICATE I, Kristy Doll, City Secretary, do hereby certify that the above notice was posted on the City Hall bulletin board, a place convenient and readily accessible to the general public at all times, and to the City’s website, www.HuntsvilleTX.gov, in compliance with Chapter 551, Texas Government Code. DATE OF POSTING: July 29, 2022 Kristy Doll TIME OF POSTING: 10:30 a.m. Kristy Doll, City Secretary TAKEN DOWN: Page 3 of 41 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA 8/2/2022 Agenda Item Number: a. Agenda Item: Receive Consultant's Recommendations on Development Districts Initiating Department/Presenter: Development Services Presenter: Armon Irones, City Planner Recommended Motion: None Strategic Initiative: Goal #3, Economic Development – Promote and enhance a strong and diverse economy. Discussion: Previous Council Action: Financial Implications: Approvals: Kristy Doll Aron Kulhavy Associated Information: Page 4 of 41 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA 8/2/2022 Agenda Item Number: a. Agenda Item: Public Hearing to hear testimony concerning the consideration of a Conditional Use Permit Application for the creation of a Vehicle Maintenance Shop to be developed on property located at I-45 North Feeder Road on Walker County Property ID #34333. Initiating Department/Presenter: Development Services Presenter: Armon Irones, City Planner Recommended Motion: Public Hearing Only- No action required Strategic Initiative: Strategic Initiative Goal #3, Economic Development- To promote and enhance a strong and diverse economy. Discussion: Previous Council Action: None Financial Implications: None Approvals: Kevin Byal Kristy Doll Rick Rudometkin Aron Kulhavy Kristy Doll Associated Information: Page 5 of 41 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA 8/2/2022 Agenda Item Number: 1.a. Agenda Item: Consider approving the Minutes from the July 19, 2022, Regular City Council Meeting Initiating Department/Presenter: City Secretary Presenter: Kristy Doll, City Secretary Recommended Motion: Move to approve the Minutes from the July 19, 2022, Regular City Council Meeting. Strategic Initiative: Discussion: Previous Council Action: Financial Implications: Approvals: Kristy Doll Associated Information: 1. July 19, 2022 City Council Meeting Minutes Page 6 of 41 1 MINUTES FROM THE HUNTSVILLE CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING HELD ON THE 19th DAY OF JULY 2022, IN THE CITY HALL, LOCATED AT 1212 AVENUE M, IN THE CITY OF HUNTSVILLE, COUNTY OF WALKER, TEXAS, AT 6:00 P.M. The Council met in a workshop and regular session with the following: COUNCILMEMBERS PRESENT: Mayor Brauninger, Mayor Pro Tem Humphrey, Councilmember Ward 1 Beebe, Councilmember At-Large Position 1 Lyle, Councilmember At- Large Position 2 Mullins, Councilmember Ward 3 Massey, Councilmember At-Large Position 3 McKenzie, Councilmember Ward 4 Strong, Councilmember At-Large Position 4 Graham COUNCILMEMBERS ABSENT: Councilmember Mullins OFFICERS PRESENT: Aron Kulhavy, City Manager; Kristy Doll, City Secretary; Leonard Schneider, City Attorney WORKSHOP (5:00 P.M.) a. Budget presentation for FY 22-23 Budget Steve Ritter, Finance Director MAIN SESSION (6:00 p.m.) CALL TO ORDER (6:00 p.m.) Mayor Brauninger called the meeting to order at 6:00 p.m. INVOCATION AND PLEDGES - U.S. Flag and Texas Flag: Honor the Texas Flag. I pledge allegiance to thee, Texas, one state, under God, one, and indivisible. Councilmember Bert Lyle gave the invocation and pledges were led by Mayor Brauninger. PUBLIC HEARING a.Public hearing to hear comments on the City’s intent to submit a grant application to the U.S. Department of Justice for the FY 2022 Local Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) Program and to enter into an Interlocal Agreement with Walker County. Steve Ritter, Finance Director Mayor Brauninger opened the Public Hearing at 6:02 p.m. No Public comments were heard in support of or in opposition of the City’s intent to submit a grant application to the U.S. Department of Justice for the FY 2022 Local Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) Program and to enter into an Interlocal Agreement with Walker County. Mayor Brauninger closed the Public Hearing at 6:04 p.m. Page 7 of 41 2 1. CONSENT AGENDA The presiding officer will call for public comments before action is taken on these items. (Approval of Consent Agenda authorizes the City Manager to implement each item in accordance with staff recommendations. An item may be removed from the Consent Agenda and added to the Statutory Agenda for full discussion by request of a member of Council.) a. Consider approving the Minutes from the July 5, 2022 Regular City Council Meeting. Kristy Doll, City Secretary b. Consider approving the 2022 Election Services Contract and Joint Election Agreement with Walker County for the November 8, 2022, General Election, for the purpose of electing four (4) Council-at-Large Councilmembers to serve two- year terms. Kristy Doll, City Secretary c. Consider adopting Ordinance No. 2022-20 Ordering a Municipal Election to be held on November 8, 2022, General Election to elect four (4) Council-at-Large Councilmember positions to serve two-year terms. Kristy Doll, City Secretary Councilmember Daiquiri Beebe made a motion to approve the Consent Agenda items a, b, and c. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Vicki McKenzie. The motion passed 8- 0. Yes - Andy Brauninger, Russell Humphrey, Daiquiri Beebe, Vicki McKenzie, Deloris Massey, Jon Strong, Pat Graham, Bert Lyle; No – None. Councilmember Deandra (Dee) Mullins arrived at 6:06 p.m. 2. STATUTORY AGENDA a. Consider authorizing the City Manager to apply for the U.S. Department of Justice – FY 2022 Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) Program, enter into an Interlocal Agreement with Walker County, and adopt Resolution 2022-21 in support of the same. Steve Ritter, Finance Director Councilmember Russell Humphrey made a motion to authorize the City Manager to apply for the U.S. Department of Justice – FY 2022 Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) Program, enter into an Interlocal Agreement with Walker County, and adopt Resolution 2022-21 in support of the same. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Pat Graham. The motion passed 9-0. Yes - Andy Brauninger, Russell Humphrey, Vicki McKenzie, Deloris Massey, Jon Strong, Pat Graham, Bert Lyle; Daiquiri Beebe, Deandra (Dee) Mullins; No – None b. Consider adopting Resolution No. 2022-22 - Adopting a Proclamation Policy Kristy Doll, City Secretary Page 8 of 41 3 Councilmember Daiquiri Beebe made a motion to adopt Resolution No. 2022-22 - Adopting a Proclamation Policy. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Vicki McKenzie. The motion passed 9-0. Yes - Andy Brauninger, Russell Humphrey, Vicki McKenzie, Deloris Massey, Jon Strong, Pat Graham, Bert Lyle; Daiquiri Beebe, Deandra (Dee) Mullins; No – None Councilmember Mullins made a motion to amend the main motion to include the words “Walker County” in the policy under the first bullet point. The motion dies for lack of second. c. FIRST READING: Consider adopting Ordinance No. 2022-21 to suspend the effective date on the proposed Entergy base rate increase of 11.2% by an additional 90 days. Leonard Schneider, City Attorney Councilmember Russell Humphrey made a motion to waive the two reading requirement and adopt Ordinance No. 2022-21 to suspend the effective date on the proposed Entergy base rate increase of 11.2% by an additional 90 days. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Pat Graham. The motion passed 9-0. Yes - Andy Brauninger, Russell Humphrey, Vicki McKenzie, Deloris Massey, Jon Strong, Pat Graham, Bert Lyle; Daiquiri Beebe, Deandra (Dee) Mullins; No – None 3. CITY COUNCIL/MAYOR/CITY MANAGER 4. REQUESTS FOR CITIZEN PARTICIPATION (An opportunity for citizens to be heard on any topic and for the City Council to participate in the discussion. No action will be taken.) a. Mr. Paul Antwine - White line by stop signs Paul Antwine Mr. Antwine presented pictures and spoke regarding the white lines by stop signs in the city. 5. MEDIA INQUIRIES RELATED TO MATTERS ON THE AGENDA None 6. ITEMS OF COMMUNITY INTEREST Mayor and Council announced items of community interest. 7. EXECUTIVE SESSION a. City Council will convene in closed session as authorized by Texas Government Code, Chapter 551, Section 551.071 to receive legal advice on the proposed TDCJ 2022 Bat Exclusion Project regarding the TDCJ Cotton Warehouse located in the City of Huntsville. Russell Humphrey, Mayor Pro Tem Leonard Schneider, City Attorney Page 9 of 41 4 Council convened into Executive Session at 6:33 p.m. 8. RECONVENE Take action on item discussed in executive session, if needed. Reconvened from Executive Session into Open Session at 7:25 p.m. ADJOURNMENT Mayor Brauninger adjourned the meeting without objection at 7:25 p.m. ATTEST: CITY OF HUNTSVILLE ____________________________ ________________________________ Kristy Doll, City Secretary Andy Brauninger, Mayor Page 10 of 41 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA 8/2/2022 Agenda Item Number: 1.b. Agenda Item: Consider adoption of Ordinance 2022-22 to amend the budget for FY 21-22 and/or CIP Project budgets Initiating Department/Presenter: Finance Presenter: Steve Ritter, Finance Director Recommended Motion: Move to adopt Ordinance 2022-22 to amend the budget for FY 21-22 and/or CIP Project budgets. Strategic Initiative: Goal #6 - Finance - Provide a sustainable, efficient and fiscally sound government through conservative fiscal practices and resource management. Discussion: Detailed explanations for the Budget Amendments are provided in the attachment, Exhibit A, to the Ordinance. The Budget Amendments were discussed with the Finance Committee at their July 19, 2022 meeting. Previous Council Action: None Financial Implications: See the attached Ordinance and related Budget Amendment (Exhibit A) Approvals: Steve Ritter Rick Rudometkin Aron Kulhavy Kristy Doll Associated Information: 1. ORDINANCE 2022-22 - Budget Amendments 8.2.22 council meeting 2. BAs 8-2-22 CC Page 11 of 41 ORDINANCE NO. 2022-22 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF HUNTSVILLE, TEXAS, AMENDING THE 2021- 2022 ANNUAL BUDGET AND CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS PROJECTS (CIP) BUDGETS, ORDINANCE NO. 2021-27 TO AMEND ADOPTED EXPENDITURES OF THE BUDGET; AND DECLARING AN EFFECTIVE DATE. WHEREAS, the 2021-2022 Annual Budget and CIP Budgets were adopted by Ordinance 2021-27 on September 21, 2021; WHEREAS, various unforeseen circumstances affecting the City have presented themselves during the course of the fiscal year; WHEREAS, the City Council considered the circumstances independently, deliberating appropriately on the associated revenues and expenditures and the overall impact on the general financial status of the City; WHEREAS, pursuant to the laws of the State of Texas and the City Charter of the City of Huntsville, Texas, the City Council has determined that it will be beneficial and advantageous to the citizens of the City of Huntsville to amend the annual budget for fiscal year 2021 – 2022 and the Capital Improvements Projects (CIP) budget as set forth herein; and WHEREAS, this ordinance combines the independent Council actions into one budget amendment document; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF HUNTSVILLE, TEXAS, that: Section 1. The findings set forth above are incorporated into the body of this ordinance. Section 2. The annual budget for fiscal year 2021 – 2022 is hereby amended to include the expenditures and revenues in Exhibit “A” and the Capital Improvements Projects budget is hereby amended to include the expenditures described in Exhibit “A” attached hereto and made a part of this ordinance as if set out verbatim herein. Section 3. All ordinances of the City in conflict with the provisions of this ordinance are hereby repealed, and all other ordinances of the City not in conflict with the provisions of this ordinance shall remain in full force and effect. Section 4. Should any section, portion, sentence, clause or phrase of this ordinance be declared unconstitutional or invalid for any reason, it shall not invalidate or impair the force or effect of any other section or portion of this ordinance. Section 5. The necessity for amending the budget for the fiscal year 2021 – 2022 and Capital Improvements Projects, as required by the laws of the State of Texas, requires that this ordinance shall take effect immediately from and after its passage, as the law in such cases provides. Section 6. This ordinance shall take effect immediately after its passage. PASSED AND APPROVED on this the 2nd day of August 2022. THE CITY OF HUNTSVILLE, TEXAS __________________________________ Andy Brauninger, Mayor ATTEST: APPROVED AS TO FORM: ____________________________ _____________________________________ Kristy Doll, City Secretary Leonard Schneider, City Attorney Page 12 of 41 Budget Amendments FY 21-22 City Council - August 2, 2022 Exhibit A Increase:General Fund - Police Victims Services - Non Capital Equp Purchases $3,717 General Fund - Grant Revenues $3,717 Explanation: The City was awarded an additional $3,717 for the Victims Services grant for the fiscal year ending September 30, 2022. The Police Department plans on purchasing 8 evidence cameras for providing video evidence for incidents potentially requiring services from Victims Services. Decrease:General Fund - City Council - Non-Profits - ARP$$425,000 Increase General Fund - NonDepartmental - Tranfer to Water/Wastewater CIP $425,000 Increase Wastewater CIP Project - McGary Creek Lift Station Expansion $425,000 Explanation: Increased need and costs for Water and Wastewater projects caused staff to re-evaluate allocation of ARP $ (approximatel $10.4M received by the City). This BA requests moving $425,000 from assisting Non-Profits to City Water and/or Wastewater CIP projects. After this Budget Amendment, if approved, there would still be $100,000 budgeted for assisting Non-Profits from ARP $ (this would be in addition to the $104,500 in the original FY 21 - 22 Budget amount from City operations (not ARP $)). ARP $ originally allocated to Water and/or Wastewater CIP projects was $7.5M. If this Budget Amendment is approved there will be $7.925M of ARP $ allocated to Water and/or Wastewater projects. Page 13 of 41 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA 8/2/2022 Agenda Item Number: 1.c. Agenda Item: Consider authorizing the City Manager to enter into an agreement with LJA Engineering for professional engineering services for the CIP FY 21-22 Storm Sewer Replacement Projects. Initiating Department/Presenter: Engineering Presenter: Kathlie Jeng-Bulloch, City Engineer Recommended Motion: Move to authorize the City Manager to enter into an agreement with LJA Engineering for professional engineering services for the CIP FY 21-22 Storm Sewer Replacement Project. Strategic Initiative: Goal #4 - Infrastructure - Ensure the quality of the City utilities, transportation and physical structures so that the City's core services can be provided in an effective and efficient manner. Discussion: The City has been replacing existing undersized and deteriorated storm sewer lines each year to the extent that funding is made available for this purpose. Replacing and/or upsizing will help reduce flooding and associated maintenance costs and improve traffic circulation during heavy rain events. A Request for Qualification (RFQ) process was conducted, and twenty-seven (27) applications from engineering firms were received. The Evaluation Committee consisted of five (5) staff members from three (3) departments. As a result of this process, the top four (4) engineering companies were selected to design four (4) separate projects. Two (2) projects are funded through ARP and three (3) through traditional CIP bond funding. This agenda item refers to the City Council approved CIP FY 21-22 Storm Sewer line Replacement Project ID # 22-10-14 along 17th Street from Ave M. to Sam Houston Ave. The Basic Engineering Service for this agreement includes: 1. Preliminary and Design – engineering design, technical specification, quality control. 2. Bidding Phase Services 3. Topographic Survey 4. TxDOT Permitting 5. Geotechnical Investigation 6. Record Drawings. LJA Engineering, Houston, Texas, who ranked the highest based on the application and oral presentation to the committee members, ARP Grant Manager and Purchasing Agent, was recommended to design Page 14 of 41 the waterline project ID #22-10-23 and the Storm Sewer Line Replacement project ID #22-10-14. Upon the City’s request, LJA Engineering met with the City staff (Engineering and Public Works Department) to discuss the line replacement in more detail. After the Scope of Work meeting, LJA Engineering provided their fee proposal to replace this Storm Sewer line. A copy of the scope, fee proposal and associated attachments received from LJA Engineering are attached to this agenda item. The total fee proposed by LJA Engineering is $76,500.00. (basic engineering services is $45,250.00 and the additional service fees are $31,250.00). The completion of the design phase is estimated to be December 2022, and construction should be started in February 2023. Previous Council Action: The City Council approved a total amount of $100,000.00 in the FY 2021-2022 budget for replacement of the 18” Storm Sewer along 17th Street from Ave M to Sam Houston Ave. Financial Implications: Item is budgeted: In the amount of: $100,000.00 Approvals: Kathlie Jeng-Bulloch Leonard Schneider Rick Rudometkin Aron Kulhavy Kristy Doll Associated Information: 1. Scope & Fee Proposal from LJA Engineering 2. Location Map of the Proposed Project Page 15 of 41 Page 16 of 41 Page 17 of 41 Page 18 of 41 Page 19 of 41 Page 20 of 41 Page 21 of 41 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA 8/2/2022 Agenda Item Number: 2.a. Agenda Item: Consider approving a Conditional Use Permit Application for the creation of a Vehicle Maintenance Shop to be developed on property located at I-45 North Feeder Road on Walker County Property ID #34333. Initiating Department/Presenter: Development Services Presenter: Armon Irones, City Planner Recommended Motion: Move to approve Conditional Use Permit Application 02-2022, allowing for the creation of a Vehicle Maintenance Shop to be developed on property located at I-45 Feeder Road on Walker County Property ID #34333, in accordance with the conditions of the draft letter of approval as recommended by the Planning Commission. Strategic Initiative: Strategic Initiative Goal #3, Economic Development- To promote and enhance a strong and diverse economy. Discussion: On July 21, 2022, following a public hearing, the Planning Commission voted 6-1 to recommend approval of Conditional Use Permit 02-2022 as detailed in the attached DRAFT Letter of Conditional Approval. This document places conditions on the development to mitigate possible nuisance effects of the development on surrounding properties. It is to be noted that even though the tract of land is approximately 12.5 acres, only 2.25 acres is planned to be developed for the vehicle shop. The proposed development will occur along the northwest portion of the property adjacent to IH- 45 Feeder Road. The applicant has agreed to the conditions recommended by the Planning Commission. The development will also be subject to all applicable provisions of the Development Code, Engineering design criteria and all other building codes. During the public hearing portion of the Planning Commission meeting, one citizen spoke out wanting to know more information about the proposed development, particularly how the applicant planned to mitigate buffering of the project. Planning staff did receive one email from a citizen that was in opposition to the proposed project. Previous Council Action: None Financial Implications: There is no financial impact associated with this item. Approvals: Kevin Byal Kristy Doll Rick Rudometkin Page 22 of 41 Aron Kulhavy Associated Information: 1. CUP Application 2. Draft CUP 02-2022_Conditions Letter 3. Vicinity Map 4. CUP 02-2022 Discussion Form 5. Caliber Collision plat Page 23 of 41 Page 24 of 41         Caliber Collision – Huntsville     Conditional Use Permit Application Letter  7/12/22    Page 1  3307 W. Davis St., Suite 100 Conroe, TX 77304 P: 936-647-0420 F: 936-647-2366 www.L2Engineering.com June 24, 2022    City of Huntsville  C/o Kevin Byal  448 SH 75 N  Huntsville, TX 77340    RE: Caliber Collision – Huntsville conditional use permit application  According to Table 4.1 of the City of Huntsville Code of Ordinances, vehicle sales and service (including maintenance or  repair of new or used vehicles and vehicular equipment) requires conditional use within 200’ of the Neighborhood  Conservation (NC) District. The proposed development is an auto repair shop that lies in the M District, however, it is  within the 200’ of the NC District. A conditional use permit should be considered for this development for the following  reasons:   At this time, the north property line of the development is planned to be used for detention, so no vehicles or  buildings will be immediately adjacent to the NC District.    A 6’ cedar privacy fence will also be placed along the north property line and all city required landscape will be  provided here.  Please feel free to contact me at 936‐647‐0420 if you have any questions or concerns.   Thank you,          Lesley Reel, PE  L Squared Engineering  936‐647‐0420  Lreel@L2engineering.com      Page 25 of 41       448 SH 75 N ˑ Huntsville, TX 77320‐1118 ˑ 936‐294‐5700 ˑ 936‐294‐5701 fax ˑ www.huntsvilletx.gov Our vision for the City of Huntsville is a community that is beautiful, historic, culturally   diverse, affordable, safe, and well planned with great opportunity for our citizens.  Huntsville  July 21, 2022  L Squared Engineering Attn: Lesley Reel, P.E. 3307 W. Davis Street Conroe, TX 77304 Re: CUP Application, Auto Repair Shop, IH 45 N Dear Ms. Reel, In observation of the requirements of the City Development Code, the City of Huntsville City Council consideration of Conditional Use Permit 02-2022 is subject to the following conditions: 1. A vegetative buffer shall be installed around the outer perimeter of the development to provide a sound buffer and visually screen it from other properties and/or public rights-of- way adjacent to residential properties. The vegetative buffer shall be a minimum of six (6) feet high and must be maintained in perpetuity. Fencing may also be incorporated to achieve the desired buffer. The fence must be constructed of wood, brick, split-face block, or any combination of these or similar materials that create an effective sound/visual screen. 2. Incorporated into the required sound/visual buffer on the perimeter of the development, tree planting shall be as follows: a. A minimum of one (1) 15-gallon tree shall be planted at a maximum spacing of twenty (20)-foot intervals within five (5) feet of the required property line. b. Variations in the tree planting requirements in setback areas may be permitted in effective use with existing trees and vegetation to provide an adequate landscaped buffer between the development and adjoining ROWs with residential homes. 3. Landscape Maintenance/Terms. All plants and trees shall be maintained in a healthy and thriving condition. Initially, it shall be the responsibility of the developer to maintain (water and weed) all landscaping until such time as the property is occupied by reason of lease or purchase, at which time the responsibility for such maintenance shall be transferred to the new property owner. All landscaping and irrigation shall be located on the subject property. Landscaping installed for the purpose of screening the facility may not be located in the public Right-of-Way. 4. All public/private utility, electric, gas, cable television and telephone lines shall be installed underground. C I T Y  O F Incorporated in 1845 under the Republic of Texas  Page 26 of 41       448 SH 75 N ˑ Huntsville, TX 77320‐1118 ˑ 936‐294‐5700 ˑ 936‐294‐5701 fax ˑ www.huntsvilletx.gov Our vision for the City of Huntsville is a community that is beautiful, historic, culturally   diverse, affordable, safe, and well planned with great opportunity for our citizens.  5. Photometric Lighting Plan. Any site lighting used on the property shall be shielded and/or directed away from adjacent properties. Security lighting shall not infringe on adjacent properties. Use of lowest wattage and highest energy efficiency fixture available is required. Photometric light plan shall be submitted to and approved by the City Building Official. 6. Hours of operation shall be conducted so as not to create a nuisance to the adjacent properties. 7. Access to the auto repair shop. Access to the auto repair shop will only take place along IH- 45 Feeder Road. No secondary access for this development will occur off Hickory Drive. 8. Compliance with all other applicable provisions of the City of Huntsville Development Code shall be implemented as part of this development. Please make note of the following excerpt from the Development Code, Section 12.809 Lapse of Approval. 12.809.A An approved conditional use application will lapse and have no further effect 18 months after it is approved by the City Council, unless: 1. A building permit has been issued (if required); 2. A certificate of occupancy has been issued; or 3. The conditional use has been lawfully established. 12.809.B The City Council is authorized to extend the expiration period for good cause on up to 2 separate occasions, by up to one year each. Requests for extensions must be submitted to the City Planner and forwarded to the City Council for a final decision. 12.809.C A conditional use also lapses upon revocation of a building permit or a certificate of occupancy for violations of conditions of approval or upon expiration of a building permit to carry out the work authorized by the conditional use approval. If we may be of further service to you, please do not hesitate to contact us at 936-294-5782. Respectfully,   Armon Irones Page 27 of 41 Subject Property CITY OF HUNTSVILLE, TXENGINEERING DEPARTMENT / GIS DIVISION 8 CREATED DATE: 6/30/2022 Vicinity MapHuntsville GIS Division 1 in = 200 ft 0 0.035 0.070.0175 mi On 8.5 x 11 inch Print On Any Print Size Service Layer Credits: City of Huntsville GIS Division The City of Huntsville, Texas or its employees gives NO warranty, expressed or implied, as to the accuracy, reliability, or completeness of these data. See full GIS Data Disclaimer at: www.huntsvilletx.gov/gis Page 28 of 41 1 PLANNING COMMISSION AGENDA ITEM DISCUSSION FORM Prepared by: Charles Young, Planner Armon Irones, City Planner MEETING DATE: July 21, 2022 SUBJECT: Proposed Development of an Auto Repair Shop TYPE OF REVIEW: Conditional Use Permit Applicant: Lesley Reel, L Squared Engineering LOCATION: I-45 North Feeder Road; Property ID: 34333 FACTS, CODE REQUIREMENTS AND CONDITIONS With the adoption of the updated Development Code, effective date of August 31, 2015, additional measures were placed in the code to protect the character and growth of the City from potential nuisance land uses at the request of the Planning Commission and City Council. The Development Code states that certain nuisance uses may be made appropriate through the additional scrutiny of a Conditional Use Permit (CUP). The applicant, Lesley Reel, is proposing to develop an Auto Repair Shop on property located along I-45 North Feeder Road at Property ID 34333. The subject property is approximately 12.481 acres in size and is in the Management (M) District. The subject property is currently vacant, undeveloped land. The auto repair shop will be a new business. Residential properties are located to the North, South, and East of the subject property and commercial is located to the West. Water and sanitary sewer service are available for the proposed development. A Neighborhood Conservation (NC) District is located within 200’ (feet) of the subject property. Relevant Economic Opportunity Goals and Land Use and Development Goals The following goals indicate the City’s intentions for the encouragement and promotion of new businesses while managing its future growth and development character. These goals will serve to guide decision-making by the Planning & Zoning Commission and City Council as they implement the 2040 Comprehensive Plan. there are five (5) goals listed under Economic Opportunity Goals and three (3) goals listed under Land Use and Development Goals. Goal EO1: An economically resilient business environment that supports the attraction, creation, retention, and expansion of national, state, and local employers to create a robust tax base. Goal EO5: A business climate that encourages entrepreneurs and local business start-ups to serve potential growth markets. Page 29 of 41 2 Goal LUD 1: A land use allocation and pattern that supports Huntsville’s key focuses of increasing quality housing supply, economic development opportunities, and quality of life, while maintaining its “small town” and semi-rural feel. Goal LUD 3: Focused growth within the city, promoting fiscal sustainability Interstate Highway 45 N has become an area lined with multi-family residential and commercial uses. To date, the City has not received any calls or emails from property owners that are within 300’ of the proposed development. The attached Letter of Conditional Approval provides draft conditions that would serve to mitigate possible nuisance effects of the development on surrounding properties. These conditions are intended to address noise, intrusive lighting, maintenance, visual clutter, and parking concerns, etc. CUP Process The requirements for the review and approval of a Conditional Use Permit are defined in Article 10: Development Review and Approval Procedures, Section 12.800 Conditional Uses, Development Code, effective date of August 31, 2015. Simply stated the procedure for a Conditional Use Permit is as follows:  Planning staff review application and prepare report and staff recommendation for the Planning Commission prior to the public hearing on the conditional use permit application.  Planning Commission must hold a public hearing on the proposed conditional use. Commission must then act, by simple majority vote, to recommend approval, approval with conditions, or denial of the request and convey its recommendation to City Council.  Final action on the conditional use permit is by City Council after receiving the Planning Commission recommendation on the matter. City Council must hold a public hearing and then act to approve, approve the proposed amendment with conditions, or deny the proposed conditional use. City Council may also remand the proposed conditional use application to the Planning Commission for further consideration. The conditional use permit application may be approved by simple majority. There are additional provisions for lapses in, transferability of, and amendments to approved Conditional Use Permits in the code. Please refer to Section 12.800 of the Development Code for additional details. In reviewing an application for a CUP, Section 12.808 of the Development Code states the following: No conditional use may be recommended for approval or approved unless the respective review or decision-making body determines that evidence has been submitted to support each of the following conclusions: Page 30 of 41 3 •That the proposed use is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. •That adequate utilities, roads, drainage and other necessary infrastructure facilities and public services are or will be available to serve proposed use; and •That the proposed use will not be detrimental to the health, safety, or general welfare of persons residing or working in the vicinity or be injurious to property values or improvements in the vicinity. STAFF RECOMMENDATION Interstate Highway 45 N is one of the primary corridors leading into and through the city. The subject site is positioned in an established area on IH 45 N where multi-family residential and commercial uses are prominent. Staff finds that the proposed use will not be detrimental to the health, safety, or general welfare of persons residing or working in the vicinity greater than any other use allowed by right in the Management Development District. Possible injurious effects on surrounding property value may be mitigated by the conditions of approval included in the draft Letter of Conditional Approval because the proposed conditions would provide sufficient improvements and buffering to create a safe and attractive environment for continued development of the IH 45 N corridor. Due to this, staff recommends approval of the Conditional Use Permit, with the conditions outlined in the Letter of Conditional Approval. ATTACHMENTS o Application o Vicinity map by staff o Attached Letter of Conditional Approval Page 31 of 41 Page 32 of 41 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA 8/2/2022 Agenda Item Number: 2.b. Agenda Item: FIRST READING: Consider authorizing the City Manager to award and enter into a contract with Frost Construction for Construction Services on the redesigned Martin Luther King Jr. Community Center Renovation Project. Initiating Department/Presenter: Parks and Leisure Presenter: Rick Rudometkin, Deputy City Manager Penny Joiner, Director of Parks and Leisure Recommended Motion: Recommended Motion: First Reading. No motion is required. Strategic Initiative: Goal #5, Resource Development - Enhance the quality of life for citizens, businesses and visitors by leveraging the human and fiscal resources available to the community. Discussion: The Martin Luther King, Jr. Community Center serves as a longstanding facility where numerous community members gather to celebrate various occasions. It is rented almost every weekend for birthday parties, family reunions, quinceaneras, gender reveals and much more. It has also been the home to Huntsville’s large MLK Day and Juneteenth Celebrations. On December 1, 2020, Burditt Consultants presented their findings of the Feasibility Study for renovations of the facility to the City Council. During their presentation, they noted three (3) options for improvement to the MLK, Jr. Community Center, citing Option A as the favorite amongst the Steering Committee. Option A allowed for the existing building to be renovated and brought up to code, while also adding square footage with the construction of a new facility adjacent to the existing structure. The original budget for the Martin Luther King, Jr. Community Center was $2.23M. On February 2, 2021, the City Council approved a budget amendment after receiving the feasibility study cost estimate, bringing the total project budget for the MLK, Jr. Community Center to approximately $3.050M including FF&E. The construction budget is $2.627M. After approval to enter into an agreement with Burditt Consultants, LLC by City Council on March 16, 2021, City Staff have been working with the firm on the design for the renovation of the existing MLK, Jr. Community Center as well as a new addition. On November 3, 2021, staff met with the architectural firm to discuss the cost estimates for the renovations and new construction to the Community Center. The estimates came in over budget due to increases in materials and supply shortages. The current construction cost estimate for the base project is $3.2M, or about $600k more than the original estimate. During a workshop on December 7, 2021, Burditt Consultants, LLC presented their design of the Page 33 of 41 renovated Martin Luther King, Jr. Community Center and its new addition to the City Council. After their presentation, City Council heard from staff regarding the cost estimate of the project and was presented with options on how to proceed with construction. The outcome is stated below: At the December 21st Council meeting, Councilmember Beebe made a motion to direct the City Manager to proceed with Option #3a as presented and, in the case the grants aren’t awarded, then proceed with option #1 as presented. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Graham and approved, 6-0. Option 1: Proceed with construction by advertising for bids in January and find additional funding where needed if costs are above the current budgeted amount. The recommended funding source would be General Fund Unallocated Reserves. There is about $4 million in this fund above the policy minimum. A budget amendment for the difference would be made after bids were received on the project. Option 3A: Postpone construction of the entire project and apply for grant funding for the totality of the project through the Texas Department of Housing and Community Affairs with the Texas Community Resiliency Program. This grant opportunity centers around the new construction or modification of a public facility which could be used to address a need for social services, and/or non-congregate housing in the community to possibly assist the vulnerable population from contracting or spreading COVID-19 or other communicable diseases. The proposed project is eligible for up to $5M in funding under this program and staff would submit an application to cover the cost of the entire project. Should the City receive the grant funds, the monies that the City has received in the debt issuance for this project could be used for other improvements to the facility or additional improvements located within Emancipation Park. The City was NOT selected to receive a grant for this project. The staff proceeded with the project as outlined in option #1 above as directed by the Council. The bids were received and opened May 25th 2022. Four proposals were received and bids ranged from $5M to $6M dollars. At a Council workshop on June 7th, 2022, the bids were discussed and option #3 from that presentation was selected to move forward with. Frost Construction, who was selected as the contractor, will work with the architect to reduce the project scope to include only a portion of the project: remodeling and expansion of the existing facility and removal of identified areas to bring it within budget. The current budget is $2.627M with a not to exceed "council approved" amount of approximately $3.2M. We were hopeful the cost was lower as this project is mostly a remodel and not new construction. (Additional building plans have already been prepared for future consideration). Unfortunately, after reducing the scope by removing building B and the basketball pavilion parking lot, Frost Construction submitted a proposal of $3.53MM. That is over the current budget of $2.627M and over the not-to-exceed amount of $3.2M. Burditt and Frost worked through the final value engineering (VE) options and Frost Construction was able to reduce the total cost to $3,081,395.00. (Please find the attached itemized list of the options that were removed). Previous Council Action: On February 2, 2021, the City Council approved the budget amendment for a total construction budget of $2.627M for the Martin Luther King, Jr. Community Center. On March 16, 2021, City Council approved the City Manager to enter into an agreement with Burditt Consultants, LLC for design and construction support services of the Martin Luther King, Jr. Community Center. On December 21, 2021, City Council approved the City Manager to proceed with Option #3a as presented and, in the case the grant is not awarded, then proceed with option #1 as presented. Page 34 of 41 On June 7, 2022, the bids were discussed and option #3 from that presentation was selected to move forward with. Frost Construction, who was selected as the contractor, will work with the architect to reduce the project scope to include only a portion of the project: to remodel and expand the existing facility and removal of identified areas to bring it within budget. The current budget is $2.627M with a not-to-exceed "council approved" amount of $3.2M. Financial Implications: Item is budgeted: In the amount of: $2.627M (construction only) Approvals: Leonard Schneider Rick Rudometkin Aron Kulhavy Kristy Doll Associated Information: 1. MLK Jr. Community Center - Cost Reduction Options_07.19.2022 Page 35 of 41 City of Huntsville - MLK Jr. Community Center Cost Reduction Options – 07.19.2022 MLK Jr Community Center- reduced scope and applied V.E. Options Scope remains per plans and spec's - except eliminate entire Building B, additional sections of concrete, trees, landscaping, removed generator and multi cameras, generator pad and V.E. options mentioned below: Alt #1- Removed $0.00 cost Alt#2 - Top re-surface coating and strip existing asphalt parking only deduct -$60,000 Alt#3- Removed- new cost $0.00 Owner's allowance reduced- $50,000 included in base bid a savings of deduct -$100,000 Testing allowance - $15,000 included in base bid Electrical V.E Options- deduct for all below and better pricing overall deduct -$213,155.00 1. Remove scones (12 )from windows 2. Remove pendants (8) above windows 3. Oversize Fans -equals in Lieu of Big Ass Fans 4. Aluminum feeders in lieu if copper feeders 5. Electrical panels equal in lieu of spec panels 6. V.E. Fixture Package as equals 7. Removed generator work/wiring/conduit 8. HVAC V.E. Options- deduct -$25,947.00 better pricing. This remains per plans and spec's- other options for equipment actually came in same or higher. Plumbing- remove gas associate lines to generator- deduct- $4,270.00 Generator - removed per cities approval- savings applied in electrical and plumbing already. Kitchen Appliances By Owner- (if approved)- deduct -$27,133.00 O.F.C.I Metal Wall and Roof Panels V.E. Options: S-deck in lieu of Berridge HC-16 - deduct -$17,773.00 Mac Panels remains- the Pac Clad panel cost more Tee Panel in Lieu of Zee-Lock Standing Seam deduct -$43,116.00 Brick V.E. Options- Modular size brick in lieu of Elongated brick deduct -$16,500.00 Glazing V.E. Options- deduct-$6,700.00 1. Remove Clerestory from Lobby 2. Remove dormer window 3. Remove Transom from entry door 4. Remove sidelights from door leading into the event room. Remove Acoustical Panels - Event Room- deduct -$17,780.00 Removed Folding Partition- Was in Building B only- deduct -$65,521.00 Page 36 of 41 City of Huntsville - MLK Jr. Community Center Cost Reduction Options – 07.19.2022 Eliminate Dormers (6) This would reduce glazing and additional Arch Material- see glazing and CFS Joist and Beams for cost savings Remove Sunshade louvers from Entry- deduct -$27,000.00 FRP in lieu of Ceramic Tile in Kitchen area all walls- deduct -$4,400.00 Flooring V.E. Options- midgrade VCT 12" x 12" in lieu of 18" x 18" LVT- maintain pattern best possible- deduct - $6,185.00 Concrete and Earthwork- remove Generator Pad- deduct -$5,500.00 Sidewalk in lieu of part of composite decking add +$5,100.00 12' x 33' straight canopy in lieu of L shape canopy deduct - $9,000.00 Eliminate 6 Dormer CFS Joists and Beams and misc - deduct -$36,000.00 Grass sod in lieu of Composite decking -deduct -$68,000.00 Total V.E. Options savings including Alt #2 and adjusted allowance deduct -$748,880.00 Additional savings with better pricing across all trades deduct -$93,725.00 New Contract Amount $3,081,395.00 Page 37 of 41 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA 8/2/2022 Agenda Item Number: 2.c. Agenda Item: Consider approval of announcing the City Council’s intention to adopt a tax rate in compliance with the Texas State’s Truth in Taxation laws; a rate not to exceed $0.3075 per $100 valuation for the City’s 2022 – 2023 Fiscal Year (Tax Year 2022). Roll call vote Initiating Department/Presenter: Finance Presenter: Steve Ritter, Finance Director Recommended Motion: Move to approve the City Council’s intention to adopt a tax rate in compliance with the Texas State’s Truth in Taxation laws; a rate not to exceed $0.3075 per $100 valuation for the City’s 2022 – 2023 Fiscal Year (Tax Year 2022). Roll call vote Strategic Initiative: Goal #6 - Finance - Provide a sustainable, efficient and fiscally sound government through conservative fiscal practices and resource management. Discussion: In order to comply with State “Truth-in-Taxation” laws, the City Council must announce its intent to adopt a tax rate. Making this announcement using language in the recommended motion, the Council may ultimately adopt a rate below the amount declared but cannot adopt a rate that exceeds the maximum rate amount declared. The rate used currently for preparing the FY 22-23 Budget is $0.2926. Using the $0.3075 rate as the proposed “not to exceed” rate for this agenda item allows for flexibility to adopt a property tax rate above the “No-New-Revenue” rate and above the rate currently used for the FY 22-23 Budget should Council desire to increase the budget for any operational expenditures of the General Fund in excess of the City Manager’s proposed budget for FY 22-23. The $0.3075 rate is the current FY 21-22 rate. This proposed "not to exceed" property tax rate is below the $0.3327 “Voter-Approval” rate provided by the Walker County Appraisal District and exceeds the $0.2836 “No-New-Revenue” rate which is also provided by the Walker County Appraisal District. Because the tax rate included in this agenda item exceeds the “No-New-Revenue” rate (the tax rate at which the City would collect the same amount of property tax in FY 22-23 as it will for FY 21-22; (excluding new property added to the rolls) a public hearing on the Tax Rate will be required. In order to comply with timing requirements in the “Truth-in- Taxation” laws for public hearings and adoption of the FY 2022 – 2023 Budget and Tax Rate the Public Hearing on the Tax Rate should be held during the September 20, 2022 meeting. Senate Bill 2 from the 2019 Texas Legislative session now only requires one public hearing on the Tax Rate and the hearing can be at the same meeting as when the actual vote on the rate is scheduled. The actual vote to adopt a Tax Rate will be scheduled for the September 20, 2022 City Council meeting. Staff will ensure all required publishings and notices are made. The Notice document included in this agenda item will be published in the Huntsville Item and will be posted on the City's website. Page 38 of 41 Previous Council Action: No previous Council action. Financial Implications: There is no financial impact associated with this item. The actual fiscal impact of this comes formally with the budget and tax rate adoption in September. Approvals: Rick Rudometkin Aron Kulhavy Kristy Doll Aron Kulhavy Associated Information: 1. Notice - CC intention to adopt prop tax rate - not to exceed Page 39 of 41 NOTICE OF 2022 TAX YEAR PROPOSED PROPERTY TAX RATE FOR CITY of HUNTSVILLE A tax rate not to exceed $ ____0.3075_____ per $100 valuation has been proposed for adoption by the governing body of City of Huntsville. This rate exceeds the lower of the no-new-revenue or voter- approval tax rate and state law requires that a public hearing be held by the governing body before adopting the proposed tax rate. The governing body of City of Huntsville proposes to use revenue attributable to the tax rate increase for the purpose of increased cost of providing Police and Fire protection, Street maintenance, Library and Parks operations, and other General Fund operational costs. PROPOSED TAX RATE (Not to exceed) $ 0.3075 per $100 NO-NEW-REVENUE TAX RATE $ 0.2836 per $100 VOTER-APPROVAL TAX RATE $ ___0.3327 ___ per $100 The no-new-revenue tax rate is the tax rate for the 2022 tax year that will raise the same amount of property tax revenue for City of Huntsville from the same properties in both the 2021 tax year and the 2022 tax year. The voter-approval tax rate is the highest tax rate that City of Huntsville may adopt without holding an election to seek voter approval of the rate. The proposed tax rate is greater than the no-new-revenue tax rate. This means that City of Huntsville is proposing to increase property taxes for the 2022 tax year. A public hearing on the proposed tax rate will be held on September 20, 2022, 6:00 PM at City Hall, located at 1212 Avenue M, Huntsville, Texas 77340. The proposed tax rate is not greater than the voter-approval tax rate. As a result, City of Huntsville is not required to hold an election at which voters may accept or reject the proposed tax rate. However, you may express your support for or opposition to the proposed tax rate by contacting the members of the City Council of City of Huntsville at their offices or by attending the public hearing mentioned above. YOUR TAXES OWED UNDER ANY OF THE ABOVE RATES CAN BE CALCULATED AS FOLLOWS: property tax amount = tax rate x taxable value of your property / 100 Council vote from August 2, 2022 meeting on proposed tax rate (rate not to exceed $0.3075): Andy Brauninger Yes/No Daiquiri Beebe Yes/No Russell Humphrey Yes/No Deloris Massey Yes/No Jon Strong Yes/No Bert Lyle Yes/No Dee Howard Mullins Yes/No Vicki McKenzie Yes/No Pat Graham Yes/No The 86th Texas Legislature modified the manner in which the voter-approval tax rate is calculated to limit the rate of growth of property taxes in the state. Tax Year 2021 Tax Year 2022 Change Total Tax rate (per $100 of value)$0.3075 $0.3075 $0.0000 (00.0%) Average homestead taxable value $195,018 $215,361 10.4% Tax on average homestead $599 $662 $63 (9.54%) Total tax levy on all properties $7,575,842 $8,505,508 $926,666 (12.2%) For assistance with tax calculations, please contact the tax assessor for City of Huntsville at 936- 295-0402 or info@walkercad.org, or visit www.walkercountyappraisal.com for more information. Page 40 of 41 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA 8/2/2022 Agenda Item Number: 4.a. Agenda Item: Airianna Mckibbins - Reliable public transportation Initiating Department/Presenter: City Secretary Presenter: Airianna Mckibbins Recommended Motion: None Strategic Initiative: Discussion: Previous Council Action: Financial Implications: Approvals: Rick Rudometkin Aron Kulhavy Kristy Doll Associated Information: Page 41 of 41